American Idol Quandry...What to do? What to do?

My head says go with Carrie Underwood from Checotah, Oklahoma. She's good and she's an Okie.

But dammit, when Aloha Mischeaux from St. Louis found out she had made it to the top 24, her response just went straight to my heart. She came out of the elevator jumping up and down and squealing and talkingaboutthisfast but then she came to a stand still and said the magic words, "I need a doughnut." Now how can you not love that?